While we upload our own footage from the concert, enjoy listening/watching “Last Christmas” live at Citadel. Enjoy and thanks thdtan0914 for the video. (Thanks Erlend for the head’s up!)
Masquerade | Tell Me Lies | Time’s Up | Hair | Hot Mess
What If | Crank It Up | It’s Alright, It’s OK | Last Christmas


























thats lipsinging right?
IM SO HAPPY SHE SAND THIS CAUSE THIS SONG IS IMPORTANT TO ME AND AHH<3
it’s live mapi.
I don’t think this is lypsinching cz audrey said that she was def singing live!
and if you check the other performances, it’s live
ashley gave a of a show last night
she did so great “time’s up” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EKjNW9QPmQ
Ahh that’s made me feel all Christmy now
She sounded so good, I loooved it, thank you for posting this!
Woah, what happened there, it made me feel Christmasy*
She awesome those singing lessons have really paid off:) It definetly live:)
Ashley’s voice has been getting better and better
She did amazing (:
i agree, i was surprised at how good time’s up was. i liked it on the cd, but it wasn’t my favorite and hearing it live made me like it way more!
overall she sounded amazing and i can’t believe it’s live. her voice has seriously developed!
some parts are not live, like the echos on time’s up and crank it up, but it’s just a few parts and not the important parts, she did an amazing job!!!
she has a backup singer there with her that is echoing her. she’s singing live.
omg i love this song
she did so amazing live!!
i’ve never heard her singing this song really live omg i’m so happy!!
love this song means so much to me!!!(L)!!!!!
@v u can see that caro clark isnt singing those echos lol but again, there are a few parts, i think she did sang live except for those echos
i think she sang the line that echoes, and the electronics on computers there make it echo. sound systems do that, they can make certain lines a person sings live echo..
as Lexi said, that’s what happened
Those are just the effects in the song. Plus she’s not even singing them so that doesn’t make her lypsinching lol
I LOVE it! I love how they added the echo it makes the whole song that much more interesting live! She did AMAZING!
It’s one thing to be curious, but some of the comments here are borderline skeptical of Ashley’s abilities and authenticity during her shows.
She sang live. End of story. She has a backup singer, yes- even a backup instrumental track, but she sang live. When the microphone left her mouth, her vocals stopped. When she took a breath- you could hear it. To be honest, she even flubbed her line slightly during It’s Alright, It’s OK- and we heard it. Why? Because she sang LIVE.
It’s getting old that her own fans and sites like ours become grounds for bickering disputes every time she puts on a show. Without fail there’s always someone questioning her performance.
@Audrey it’s just a comment on how her live shows are, she sang live, no discussions there, but i thought we can talk about it, she did it great, and it was curious, at least for me, the echo… i didnt know how it works and im glad that someone here explain it. i think no one’s being skeptical… dont make it igger that it is, no discussions or disputes
I totally agree with audrey, you can hear the breaths! And ashley has a keyboard player he can do a lot of effects with his keyboard maybe the echoes were an effect of the keyboard! Last christmas was her best performance to me and i liked that all the songs were live!
cant wait for her tour *fingerscrossed*
Cami- Again, that’s fine to be curious- my comment is geared toward those looking for an argument. Obviously, you were not someone looking to rile up trouble, thank you for that.
totally agree with audrey. these arguments are getting old, on fansites and her music boards. if you’re a fan of ashley, then you should support her, even if she didn’t sing live, which you can tell she did.
Btw, Ashley told the crowd beforehand that this was her second time performing “Time’s Up” (I have it in my video). I wonder which show she sang it at before? Maybe the Microsoft event?
@audrey maybe the soundcheck? Of the citadel concert of course xd
@audrey maybe she sang it at the gymnastics and skating event. there weren’t a lot of videos from that event, i only saw parts of two songs, so maybe no one recorded it. i would think someone would have recorded it at the microsoft event, but i don’t know. good question
haha
Lexi- Ohhh, that’s a possibility! I’m just thinking aloud, since we haven’t (to my knowledge) seen a video of her performing “Time’s Up” yet.
yeah haha. i’m pretty sure we haven’t seen a video of her performing it until last night.
audrey when will you upload your videos? i cant wait to see them and also hear what she has to say in btw songs and such. hmm i wonder where ese she performed times up. and i agree stop doubting ashley. if your fans than just be fans and support her
Charlene- Sometime tonight (sorry I don’t have an exact time frame, the file is large & will take time to upload) like I said- I got everything but Masquerade (and the end of Tell Me Lies- we were still setting up). I’m looking forward to you guys getting to see the show from my point of view!
audrey awsome i cant waIt but could you plz upload them to youtuube? my comp wont let me view anything else :/ thanks
We can’t upload to YouTube- the video is 31 minutes long.
____________________
Edit: We are going to put the full video on the site, and try uploading in parts to YouTube.
oh thank you if you could uplioad the vid in parts for me to youtube that would be amazing .c my computer wont let me view anything else thank you so much